CIS Implementation Groups (IGs) sort the 153 safeguards in CIS Controls v8 into three tiers according to an organization’s risk profile and resources. IG1 is essential cyber hygiene and contains 56 safeguards. IG2 adds 74 more for organizations with dedicated IT staff and more complex risk. IG3 adds the final 23 for organizations that handle sensitive data and face sophisticated attackers.

The groups are cumulative. IG2 includes everything in IG1, and IG3 includes everything in IG2. They exist so that a small organization is not handed a list of 153 safeguards and left to guess where to start.

IG1 vs IG2: the difference for a small business

IG1 is the 56 safeguards every organization should have, sized for a small business with no security staff. IG2 adds 74 more for organizations that employ people to manage IT and hold sensitive client or regulated data. Most small businesses, and most small-business clients of an MSP, belong in IG1 first.

IG1 vs IG2 vs IG3 at a glance

CIS Controls v8 Implementation Groups compared
IG1IG2IG3
Safeguards added567423
Cumulative total56130153
Typical organizationSmall to medium, with limited IT and security expertiseEmploys people responsible for managing and protecting IT infrastructureEmploys security experts who specialize in different areas
Data sensitivityLow. Mostly employee and financial informationSome sensitive client or enterprise data, often with compliance obligationsSensitive data and functions subject to regulatory and compliance oversight
Main concernKeeping the business running, with little tolerance for downtimeLoss of public confidence if a breach occursAvailability of services, and the confidentiality and integrity of sensitive data
Designed to stopGeneral, non-targeted attacksMore capable attackers, across departments with different risk profilesSophisticated adversaries, including zero-day attacks

What IG1 means: essential cyber hygiene

CIS calls IG1 “essential cyber hygiene” and describes it as the minimum standard of information security for every enterprise. The 56 safeguards are chosen so they can be implemented with limited expertise and with commercial off-the-shelf hardware and software.

Examples of IG1 safeguards: keep a detailed inventory of enterprise assets (1.1), address unauthorized assets (1.2), configure data access control lists (3.3), establish a secure configuration process (4.1), use DNS filtering (9.2), deploy anti-malware software and keep its signatures updating automatically (10.1 and 10.2), run a security awareness program (14.1), and designate someone to manage incident handling (17.1).

Three of the 18 controls have no IG1 safeguards at all: Control 13 (Network Monitoring and Defense), Control 16 (Application Software Security), and Control 18 (Penetration Testing). That is on purpose. All three need skills and tools that CIS does not expect an IG1 organization to have.

What IG2 adds

IG2 is for organizations that have staff whose job is to manage IT, that support several departments with different risk profiles, and that often carry a regulatory burden. Its safeguards need more specialized expertise and enterprise-grade technology to install and configure.

Examples: use an active discovery tool to find assets (1.3), maintain a data classification scheme (3.7), segment data processing and storage by sensitivity (3.12), disable unnecessary services (4.8), run automated internal vulnerability scans and remediate what they find (7.5 and 7.7), centralize security event alerting (13.1), deploy network intrusion detection (13.3), and give staff role-specific security training (14.9).

What IG3 adds

IG3 is for organizations that employ security specialists in areas such as risk management, penetration testing, and application security, and whose data or services are subject to regulatory oversight. Its 23 additional safeguards are aimed at targeted attacks by sophisticated adversaries and at reducing the impact of zero-day attacks. A successful attack on an IG3 organization can cause significant harm to the public welfare.

How to decide which group you are in

  1. Start with your data. If a breach would expose regulated or highly sensitive data, you are looking at IG2 or IG3 no matter how small you are.
  2. Look at your staffing. If nobody’s job is IT or security, IG1 is the realistic starting point. If you have dedicated IT staff, consider IG2. If you have specialized security roles, consider IG3.
  3. Consider who would attack you. Opportunistic, non-targeted attacks point to IG1. Targeted attacks by capable adversaries point to IG3.
  4. Implement IG1 first in every case. Because the groups are cumulative, IG1 is the foundation whatever your final target is.
  5. Treat the group as a starting point. CIS expects organizations to do their own risk assessment and adjust. The group is a guide, and you will not be audited against it.

When an organization sits between two groups

Real organizations do not always fit one tier. In a gap analysis I wrote for a course case study, a compromise at a company called Luigi’s, the organization sat between IG1 and IG2. It had a network operations center and a help desk, but no coordinated incident response. The analysis used IG1 safeguards plus the specific IG2 safeguards that answered facts in the case.

That produced 27 safeguards across 10 controls: 11 from IG1 and 16 from IG2. An unmanaged personal laptop reached the internal network, so safeguards 1.1 and 1.2 (IG1) applied. It was then able to reach an anonymous FTP server, which called for segmentation (12.2) and traffic filtering between segments (13.4), and both of those are IG2. The list stops at IG2 because that is where the organization sits.

Frequently asked questions

How many safeguards are in CIS IG1?
IG1 contains 56 of the 153 safeguards in CIS Controls v8. IG2 adds 74 for a cumulative 130, and IG3 adds 23 for the full 153.
Do I have to implement IG1 before IG2?
Yes, in practice. The groups are cumulative, so IG2 includes every IG1 safeguard. CIS recommends every enterprise start with IG1, which it calls essential cyber hygiene.
Is a CIS Implementation Group a certification?
No. Implementation Groups are a self-assessed way to prioritize safeguards. They are not a certification or an audit standard, although other frameworks and regulators reference the CIS Controls.
Which CIS Controls have no IG1 safeguards?
Control 13, Network Monitoring and Defense; Control 16, Application Software Security; and Control 18, Penetration Testing. All three start at IG2 because they require expertise and tooling beyond what an IG1 organization is expected to have.

Sources